Imminent signing of the Deed of Settlement has had people being invited to ‘celebrate this historic occasion’

16 December 2015

Mr Edwin Emery

Tribal Member: Ngati Kahu ki Whangaroa

Re: Imminent signing of the Deed of Settlement has had people being invited to ‘celebrate this historic occasion’

Among those celebrating will be three individuals who could be described as the ‘architects’ of this process:


Chris Finlayson, Politician – loyal to his party colleagues and their policies

As part of the current regime they are pushing through flawed ‘cookie-cutter’ treaty settlements, stamped ‘full & final’ so that White New Zealand can expunge it’s colonial past and ‘move on’.


Richard Hawk, Lawyer – a person who has been present from the start of the process

He has been the lawyer for the claim, for the iwi. Any legal document associated with this claim he would have had some input into or perhaps even authored.

One such document would be the Post Settlement Group Entity Trust Deed. Some 70 pages of ‘legal-speak’ designed with the express purpose of entrenching those who have control of assets ‘post-settlement’.

Hawk is a consultant with the legal firm ‘Jackson Russell’. Proudly displayed on the Jackson Russell website, as part of their history blurb is the following:

“1865 – 1890s: For the next 20 years or so the firm, like others in Auckland at the time, was much engaged in legal work connected with land speculation and gold mining.”

Land speculation in this context would have been the frenzied activity of white settlers acquiring land from Maori by whatever means. Parliament legalised it and the legal fraternity was the mechanism to affect it.


Peter Pangari, Real Estate Agent – this individual has all the traits necessary for his chosen occupation

I would suggest he views the land as a ‘commodity’ to be acquired as part of your ‘portfolio’.

He does have a propensity to enter properties without notification. On one occasion having to be evicted by my father.

Hawk and Pangari are mates, having met at night classes in Auckland in the 1980’s.


All three of these individuals have absolutely no bloodline connection to the lands in question, and yet they have had an impact on this iwi, way out of proportion to who they are as individuals. For the politician, the lawyer and the real estate agent – in the coming years that influence will diminish significantly.

Only 585 people of this tribe have voted to accept the ‘crumbs’ the Crown is ‘flicking to us’, a mere 15% of the iwi.

We will never know the true numbers of this tribe; however based on the Ngati Kahu ki Whangaroa Trust Board database there are 3,800 tribal members (refer NKKTB Treaty Information Booklet) – that would mean that 85% of the iwi do not wish this settlement to go ahead. Clearly those who are dissenting are a statistically significant majority.

Of the Trust Board tribal member database of 3,800, 1200 were deemed invalid (Election Services) – either under age or lying horizontal in our urupa. This suggests that the NKKWTB ‘stacked’ the database. If only 10 -20 names were deemed invalid that would be reasonable – not 1200.

To the ‘minority’ who accept this treaty settlement you will get the Treaty Settlement you deserve.

What say the Kaitiaki of this Whenua, be it the humble Kiore, the grandfather Kiwi or the ancient & revered Pohutukawa – nothing … but Absolute Silence !

Crown and Ngatikahu ki Whangaroa initialled a Deed of Settlement on 5 June 2015

Ngatikahu ki Whangaroa

The Crown and Ngatikahu ki Whangaroa initialled a Deed of Settlement on 5 June 2015. The initialled deed is available under Supporting documents below.

Deed of Settlement documents

Deed not settled at this time.

Supporting documents

File Date Size
Initialled Deed of Settlement 5 Jun 2015 991 KB
Initialled Deed Attachments  5 Jun 2015 3.3 MB
Initialled Deed Property Redress 5 Jun 2015 158 KB
Initialled Deed General Matters 5 Jun 2015 278 KB
Initialled Deed Documents 5 Jun 2015 719 KB
Refined Agreement in Principle 7 Jul 2014 1.0 MB
Agreement in Principle for the Settlement of Historical Claims 22 Dec 2007 14.4 MB
Terms of Negotiation 19 Oct 2004 2.2 MB
Recognition of Mandate  14 Oct 2004 65 KB

Draft Deed of Settlement documents from OTS (December 2014)

I’ve managed to obtain these Deed of Settlement documents dated December 2014 from OTS. Unfortunately the NKKWTB aren’t willing to provide the latest versions to our Iwi, but perhaps someone could ask them for the latest copy. While your at it could you please also ask them for a copy of the Draft PSGE Constitution as well?

51338514_Ngatikahu ki Whangaroa – General Matters_(v10)

51338681_Ngatikahu ki Whangaroa – Documents_(v10)

51338996_Ngatikahu ki Whangaroa – Attachments_(v6)

51336865_Ngatikahu ki Whangaroa – Deed of Settlement_(v11)

51338373_Ngatikahu ki Whangaroa – Property Redress_(v10)

AGENDA 16 May 2015 for next NKKWTB Hui

AGENDA 16 May 2015

SUBJECT: Agenda

VENUE: Otangaroa Marae

DATE: 16 May 2015 TIME: 10.00 am

________________________________________________________________________

  1. General Business
  2. Treasurer – Financial Report: See attached – Bills to be paid – Budget (claimant funding)
  3. Outwards Correspondence: See attached
  4. Inward Correspondence: See attached
  5. Matters Arising
  6. Minutes of Previous Meeting The minutes of the hui held at Waihapa Marae on the 21 March 2015
  7. Apologies
  8. Mihimihi
  9. Karakia
    1. Consideration to accept draft PSGE Constitution
    2. Report of meeting with OTS  DOC Covenants  Stony Creek  Redress of Kowhairoa
    3. Report of the Overlapping Claims meeting with Ngati Kahu (Chair)
    4. Trustees Travel (Manaaki)

What’s happening?

Well, the Crown have done a 180% on their offer back in July 2014, and will be giving everything back to the NKKWTB, despite numerous objections.

NKKWTB continue to make a joke of their mandate by not meeting their mandate obligations; which OTS support.

OTS continue to enable NKKWTB rather than pro-actively encouraging an amicable resolution between our Iwi.

The NKKWTB refuse to provide open and transparent communication. There have been questions raised on this site; however the NKKWTB have failed to take the opportunity to openly engage with the people they claim to represent.

A PSGE Constitution has been drafted, this is despite our Iwi not having voted on the AIP. On May 16, the NKKWTB will be seeking acceptance of the PSGE Constitution without proper consultation with our Iwi. Ella Henry is somehow running the PSGE, but I don’t remember reading that being voted on either.

The NKKWTB are planning to sign away our lands and future this June, despite the Crown’s latest offer not being presented or voted on by our Iwi.